Television Review: All Happy Families... (The Sopranos, S5X04, 2004)

All Happy Families... (S05E04)

Airdate: March 28th 2004

Written by: Toni Kalem
Directed by: Rodrigo Garcia

Running Time: 52 minutes

Long-running television series often afford their cast members opportunities to explore roles behind the camera, a tradition The Sopranos embraced by its fifth season. Among those stepping into production was Toni Kalem, known for her portrayal of recurring character Angie Bonpensiero. Though she had joined the show’s staff as a story editor earlier in the season, All Happy Families…, third episode, remains Kalem’s sole writing credit for the series.

The episode’s title draws deliberately from Leo Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina—specifically its iconic opening line: “All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.” Kalem’s script mirrors Tolstoy’s preoccupation with domestic discord, juxtaposing the crumbling dynamics of Tony Soprano’s household with the escalating power struggles within New York’s Lupertazzi crime family. Both narratives dissect how familial and organisational structures corrode under the weight of ego, betrayal, and unmet expectations. While Tony’s clan grapples with teenage rebellion and marital estrangement, New York’s mob hierarchy teeters on the brink of civil war, illustrating that dysfunction, whether domestic or professional, is universally destabilising.

The New York storyline reaches a critical juncture as Johnny Sack’s ruthless ambition sparks open conflict. By orchestrating the murder of Lorraine Calluzzo, Sack forces the reluctant Angelo Garepe to align with Little Carmine’s faction, fracturing the Lupertazzi family beyond repair. Tony Soprano, ever the pragmatist, opts for neutrality, recognising that overtly supporting either camp could embolden dissent within his own ranks. His precarious authority—already undermined by challenges from figures like Feech La Manna—relies on avoiding the perception of weakness.

At home, Tony dismisses A.J.’s academic failures as a transient adolescent phase, adopting a permissive stance that starkly contrasts with Carmela’s authoritarian “tough love.” A.J., ever the opportunist, exploits this parental divide, manipulating Carmela’s trust to sneak off to New York for a debauched night of substance abuse. Her subsequent decision to expel him from the house—forcing Tony to take responsibility—reveals the couple’s unresolved tensions. Tony’s handling of A.J., however, is telling: he weaponises humour and casual dominance to reassert control, hosting his son in a male-dominated environment devoid of maternal influence. The episode closes on Carmela, isolated in her empty home, silently questioning the consequences of her separation from Tony—a poignant visual metaphor for the costs of her fleeting independence.

The episode’s most immediate threat to Tony emerges from Feech La Manna, a newly paroled veteran whose nostalgic bravado masks a dangerous ambition. Feech’s tales of Tony’s past recklessness—such as robbing a card game under his superiors’ noses—subtly undermine the boss’s authority, framing him as an impetuous upstart rather than a seasoned leader. This dynamic reaches a crisis when Feech orchestrates an armed robbery at the wedding of Dr. Ira Fried’s daughter, directly challenging Tony’s civilian alliances. Recognising Feech’s trajectory as reminiscent of past adversaries like Richie Aprile, Tony sidesteps a bloody confrontation, instead engineering Feech’s parole violation. This resolution—brutally pragmatic yet non-lethal—showcases Tony’s evolving mastery of psychological warfare over brute force.

The Sopranos frequently blurred reality and fiction through self-aware casting, a tradition upheld here. Frankie Valli, the legendary singer name-dropped in prior episodes, finally appears as Rusty Millio, a Lupertazzi captain. The cameo-laden card game scene—featuring real-life TV producer Bernie Brillstein and others—further immerses the viewer in the show’s quasi-autobiographical texture, nodding to its own cultural footprint.

The introduction of Robert Wegler, A.J.’s counsellor, injects a potential romantic subplot for Carmela. David Strathairn’s understated performance lends gravitas, yet the script’s allusion to Madame Bovary—a comparison drawn by Wegler himself—feels overly contrived. While the reference underscores Carmela’s stifled aspirations, it risks reducing her arc to literary cliché, a rare misstep in a series typically lauded for nuanced characterisation.

The demise of Lorraine Calluzzo, portrayed by 1970s pop culture icon Patti D’Arbanville, epitomises the series’ merciless approach to character arcs. After her humiliating deposition in the prior episode, Lorraine is executed even more humiliatingly, her death, almost identical to Brendan Filone in Season 1, reflecting the show’s ethos of “equality” in mob justice—a stark rebuttal to gendered critiques. Lorraine’s fate underscores that in The Sopranos, incompetence and hubris are punished indiscriminately, regardless of gender. While some modern critics might decry her treatment as exploitative, it aligns with the show’s unflinching realism: in this world, power—not identity—dictates survival.

“All Happy Families…” exemplifies The Sopranos at its most thematically audacious, weaving literary allusions, familial strife, and mob politics into a cohesive whole. Kalem’s script navigates these threads with confidence, balancing character-driven drama with taut suspense. Though minor elements flirt with cliché—Wegler’s Bovary reference, for instance—the episode’s strengths lie in its psychological complexity and willingness to subvert expectations.

RATING: 7/10 (+++)

Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo

InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e

BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9

Posted Using INLEO